Sittlichkeit, Religion und Geschichte in der Philosophie Kants

Geismann, Georg (2000) Sittlichkeit, Religion und Geschichte in der Philosophie Kants. Jahrbuch für Recht und Ethik, 8. pp. 437-531.

[img]
Preview
PDF
9195.0.sittlich.pdf

Download (274kB)

Abstract

Dieser Beitrag verfolgt ein systematisches Ziel. Er will weder eine Entwicklung in Kants Denken noch die Gestalt aufzeigen, die es in einem bestimmten Werk Kants angenommen hat. Er basiert auf der Überzeugung eines seit der Kritik der reinen Vernunft im wesentlichen konsistenten systematischen Zusammenhangs dieses Denkens. Unterschiede, die bei einem Vergleich zwischen den einzelnen Werken sichtbar werden, beruhen zumeist auf einer jeweils unterschiedlichen Aufgabenstellung und bestätigen bei näherer Betrachtung oft in verblüffender Weise eben jenen Zusammenhang. So erklärt es sich auch, daß in dem Beitrag häufig zum selben Punkt aus verschiedenen Schriften zitiert bzw. auf solche verwiesen wird. Summary The contribution starts with a concise account of Kant's moral philosophy. It is shown that a moral will is necessarily an autonomous will and that only the formal" character of the moral law can establish its universal validity. Some widespread misunderstandings are discussed, especially with regard to the alleged emptiness of the moral law; the relationship between duty and inclination; the role of natural incentives in a moral will; and the necessary objects of such a will. This leads to the idea of the highest good (happiness in proportion to worthiness) as the objective final end and duty of a finite rational being. Again, typical misunderstandings are dealt with: the reproach of eudaimonism, and heteronomy, and the role of the highest good as incentive; and an alleged inconsistency between Analytic and Dialectic of the Second Critique. In the then following discussion of Kant's doctrine of the postulates and his philosophy of religion, it is shown that religion is totally dependent on morality as philosophy of religion is on moral philosophy; that a belief in God is required neither for the validity of the moral law nor for the obedience to it; that the so-called moral proof is not a proof of God's existence, but only of the practical necessity of its assumption; and that the idea of the highest good refers throughout exclusively to another world. The last chapter first gives a concise account of Kant's teleological philosophy of history and then comes to the result of the whole inquiry: that there is a principle difference between philosophy of religion and philosophy of history which makes them not only independent of each other, but also keeps them in well distinguished fields. The philosophy of religion presupposes moral philosophy. Its main function is to determine what the idea of God morally means to man. Its achievement is to yield a reason of belief for the hope that the realization of the highest moral good is possible and that therefore the moral life of man is not necessarily pointless, as long as he fulfills his respective duty. It has (practical) meaning only for the one who is conscious of being subject to the moral law and ready to act accordingly. The philosophy of history on the other hand presupposes especially the doctrine of right. Its main function is to determine what the future of mankind on earth politically means to man. Its achievement is to yield empirical reasons for the hope that the realization of the highest political good is possible and that therefore the political life of man is not necessarily pointless, as long as he fulfills his respective duty. It has (practical) meaning only for the one who is conscious of being subject to the law of right and ready to act accordingly, although, it is true, the attainment of the historical aim itself is possible even by acting from purely prudential reasons.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Kant, Moralisches Gesetz, Sittlichkeit, Geschichte
Subjects: Philosophie > Geschichte der Philosophie > e) 18.Jahrhundert
Depositing User: Stefan Köstenbauer
Date Deposited: 25 Aug 2005
Last Modified: 08 Sep 2011 18:51
URI: http://sammelpunkt.philo.at/id/eprint/1065

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year